I got another one of those calls today. I have only gotten a small number of them. My former husband Mike got one - and he hasn't forgotten it to this day. I was cooking dinner or lunch or something when the call came in and I could hear "the voice" clear across the room.
That would be a "Call from Harlan Ellison."
These calls are not lightly taken, so after some thought and writing on other subjects, I'd like to address something important for people to understand about Harlan Ellison. It's a subject that now, I can view all ways having been on both sides of the desk, and a subject about which I can speak clearly - Harlan Ellison was and is a great teacher.
There are dozens of lists of qualities of great teachers on the internet. As somebody who is now also a pretty good teacher, I can give my own list of qualities that great teachers possess.
A great teacher should . . .
- Be open-minded and establish an atmosphere of respect.
- Have empathy and understanding toward students.
- Put the students and their learning first.
- Have clear command of the subject.
- Communicate expectations and expected performance clearly.
- Have clear command of the group or learning environment.
- Be flexible.
- Be passionate.
- Be committed.
- Be effective.
- Be inspirational.
By those standards, which are my own standards for myself, the Harlan Ellison that was my teacher many years ago (a shocking number - I just had my 25th college reunion, so more than 2 decades ago) easily met each of these criteria. I always told people that Algis Budrys was my favorite Clarion teacher. He was. He was the most clear of the six instructors. Kate Wilhelm was the most empathetic. Damon Knight had the aura of master.
Harlan was the best.
This pipe picture above isn't just here because that is the Harlan "I remember," it's here for an important reason. The picture could easily convince anyone that Harlan smoked a pipe. He did not. He told me that he never had smoked, nor did he drink. This is a posed picture; the pipe is for "effect." It's not lit and it never was lit. I could probably find, and have heard many people insist in person, that Harlan's a big drinker and big smoker. No, he isn't, no, he wouldn't, and no he didn't and doesn't. It's all lies.
I understand now that Harlan has been "controversial" because people don't perceive the several layers of irony in which he sometimes cloaks his words and actions, and because they also fail to perceive that he has always communicated from a deep, honest emotional core. It's in his writing. It is his writing. It took me years to understand and acknowledge the reality of the greater than average number of people in the sci-fi and fantasy field that were crippled emotionally, or who simply didn't have the normal range of emotions, or a normal level of empathy possessed by the majority of the general population. It's truly a clash of titanic human forces -- the enlightened, empathetic humanist Harlan vs. frightened dogmatic . . . skeptics.
I like to bring the subject of aspirations up to my students. My aspirations were never huge. I've achieved every aspiration I ever had. Putting that aside, ten years ago, when I asked students what they most wanted, "fame" came out on top, "money" or "success," second. For the past three or four years, "fame" is barely mentioned, and while "money" and "success" moved ahead, today the top aspiration is "happiness."
That makes me very happy for our world. Why? Because people now understand that fame is a curse, not a blessing. If Britney Spears didn't do anything else, she should always be remembered as the young woman who taught everybody that there is such a thing as "too much fame." As to "money" and "success," you know what else people say that's very true: you aren't taking either one of those with you when you go.
All that is left is happiness, which in large part, at least for me, derives from knowing who I am and behaving with honesty and integrity. Because I write, honesty and integrity in what I put down on paper always has to come first.
Which leaves me with the great teacher. I've had more than enough personal attack and abuse to last a lifetime myself. What it did for me is assist me in removing any pretense regarding human nature at its worst. However bad I might imagine that to be, I now know that all I have to do is double or triple that, and come out pretty close to how bad people can get in their abuse of others. I do have quite an imagination and it's a fantastic assistance in predicting what people who are unhappy, uncomfortable and narrow-minded will do in pursuit of making themselves feel better for a moment or two. The best moments in my life occur every morning when I wake up, wash my face and brush my teeth, and look myself in the eye in the mirror. Harlan didn't teach me that, but he gave me a huge boost along that path. Every quality, and every step I listed above: that's what a great teacher does. Teaching is one of the foundations of human culture -- it may be the foundation.
I am by far from Harlan's best, most diligent, most faithful student. How many have read his books? How many have worked with him and learned from him? So many - and his books will live and grow. Every generation, more and more people will discover that genuine, true, heartfelt voice.
I hope in some way this will put paid to some of the abuse that Harlan has had to endure in recent years via the internet. People may have noticed that I'm writing fewer internet posts than before. I am working on a new book, and I've had a lot of writing projects between the spring and now. I've decided to start writing for younger readers. I was a 10th grade student myself when I first read Dangerous Visions, and I bought my precious little Shatterday with money from my first paying job during my junior year of high school. A good story for kids to start with is "Jeffty is Five." It will keep them thinking for quite some time.